11 Comments
User's avatar
Scott Brockway's avatar

A conservative can listen to, consider, or ignore a contrary opinion. (CPAC, in its current form, doesn’t count …). A leftist must burn mega-joules of energy trying to extinguish a contrary opinion. Perhaps one day this will change. Perhaps it already is changing …

Expand full comment
Don Huddleston's avatar

I’m curious what percentage of Republican voters do you think are conservative in the way you define it? CPAC and MAGA seem just as skilled as leftists in extinguishing contrary opinions. (Contrary opinions are what I grew up with - liberal parents and conservative grandparents. Fun dinners.)

Expand full comment
Scott Brockway's avatar

Too few, I am afraid. You are spot on regarding MAGA’s intolerance of dissent. (Shut up … they explained.). Considering that the Populist Right’s definition of conservatism is “Whatever the Donald happens to be feeling right now,” too many conservative voices have been shouted down. I think that at least an equal number of Republican voters voted against Harris rather than voted for Trump. For the next four years I will salute this administration for the good things it does and suggest better courses of action in those areas I feel it falls short.

Expand full comment
Paul Britton's avatar

Jay — one of the reasons I enjoy reading your pieces is that our reading interests frequently overlap. I have, for instance, enthusiastically recommended A House for Mr Biswas to a number of friends and relatives. A marvelous novel. And Vargas Llosa’s The Feast of the Goat— absolutely brilliant.

Expand full comment
francesca's avatar

I also love A House for Mr Biswas. I love the Father lying on his cot in their house, reading stoic philosophy.

Expand full comment
Paul Britton's avatar

How much all of us humans have in common!

We’re never vacationed in the Caribbean, but if we ever decide to, I want to visit Trinidad-Tobago.

Expand full comment
Lara Mason's avatar

One of my most valued possessions (though it probably only has great value to me, since the monetary value of the item is not excessive), is a letter I bought from Sotheby's twenty-five years ago back when they had a partnership with Amazon. It's from 1957 and is signed by T.S. Eliot (my favorite modern poet) on his Faber and Faber Limited letterhead, in which Eliot agrees to be interviewed by a biographer of Ezra Pound, provided he can supply a letter of authorization from the Pounds. I very much identified with that reference today.

Expand full comment
Jay Nordlinger's avatar

Highly interesting. Thx.

Expand full comment
Roger Nordlinger's avatar

Brilliant!

Expand full comment
Jay Nordlinger's avatar

Thank you, cuz.

Expand full comment
Don Huddleston's avatar

Enjoyed your commencement speech examples. Inspiring! UVA in 1979 had the chairman of ATT. 30 minutes of business world cliches. Perhaps some of my classmates liked it.

Expand full comment