Mr. Nordlinger: Regarding your reader, I fail to see how NATO "encroached on Russia." Russia has now demanded that Finland withdraw from NATO. It is clear Russia fears a NATO Article 5 response to their desired attack on Finland. Putin is obviously desperate not to accidentally fall out a window in the Kremlin.
Jay raised an interesting point about using “American” to describe every man in the Continental Army who fought the British in the Battle of Cowpens on January17, 1781. Per Google AI, that Continental Army division, led by Brigadier General Daniel Morgan, included about 450 to 500 Continental regulars (from Maryland and Delaware) and roughly 800 to 1,000 state militiamen from North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, and Virginia.
I asked Google AI this question: “Europeans referred to colonists in North America as Americans but did the colonists? Didn't they identify as Virginians, Pennsylvanians, Marylanders, etc.?”
This was Google AI’s answer:
Yes, North American colonists primarily identified with their specific colony—such as Virginians, Pennsylvanians, or Marylanders—and as British subjects, rather than as "Americans" in a national sense.
• PRIMARY LOCAL AND IMPERIAL LOYALTIES: For most of the colonial era, a person's foundational identity was tied to their local province, town, or colony, as well as their status as a subject of the British Crown. Inter-colonial rivalries and vast geographic distances meant a resident of Massachusetts rarely felt a shared national kinship with a resident of South Carolina.
• GEOGRAPHIC VS. NATIONAL LABEL: While Europeans and British authorities used "American" as early as the 1600s, it functioned strictly as a geographic descriptor—much like calling someone a "southerner" or "islander"—rather than a nationality.
• SHIFT DURING THE REVOLUTION: A broader sense of a shared "American" identity began to take root through collective resistance to British taxation and policies in the 1760s and 1770s, accelerated by the Second Continental Congress officially adopting the name United States of America in 1776. However, strong state-level identities remained dominant for decades afterward.
Here are two of the links Google AI provided to information sources:
Jay: I agree with Professor Thornton that the "Collected Works of William Shakespeare" is one of the greatest books ever written, but you cannot overlook the "The Collected Works of Sherlock Holmes" by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle!! First read them in 7th grade and was hooked on mysteries ever since. I reread them every few years. And do not forget the DVD sets, starring Basil Rathbone, then Jeremy Brett, and the modern version with Benedict Cumberbatch. I guess you have to say this old geezer is a Sherlock Holmes fan. 🤔😊
Camp Meeting....great album from Bruce Hornsby accompanied by two of the greatest...Jack DeJohnette and Christian McBride.
On another note,SC has the home to the greatest number of Loyalist and if not for the hill people of Tennessee and North Carolina,it may be more Tea Time than Tee Time down that way !
And Jay !!! Augusta G A ...home to the Godfather of Soul,Mr.Please,Please,Please himself ...the Hardest Working Man in Show Business:
Regarding the woman who will not subscribe due to your leanings towards Israel. Seems a bit short sighted to me. How does one learn to curate an opinion if they don't at least listen to opposing viewpoints? I don't agree with everything I read,but I read both sides. Same argument to folks that don't consider history worth studying. How do you know where you're going,if you don't know where you've been?
I apologize to any readers who are not comfortable with my take.
Between 1780 and 1820 or so, the largest cohort of immigrants to “Canada” were United Empire Loyalists who fled the Colonies or were driven out of your young Country.
So, even though these folks were technically Americans, they decided to leave. Canada, of course, was not yet a Dominion, but this is considered part of Canadian history. Those Loyalists are considered early Canadians.
I would describe the Revolutionary warriors as Americans, and the new, fledgling Country as America.
Even if the American side lost, and the British retained some standing, there would still remain that remnant of folks who believed in the bigger American ideal, and ethos.
I hope that makes sense, and I hope it sheds a different perspective on the discussion.
Yes, it is easy to forget that the American Revolution did not just create the United States, it also created Canada. It did so by producing a division where no division had existed before. Prior to that revolution the eastern seaboard of North America (apart from what is now Florida) was made up entirely of British colonies, all equally subject to the Crown.
It’s an interesting thought experiment to wonder how things would have subsequently developed if the American Revolution had never happened, or if the revolutionaries had lost the war.
Edited to add: it’s also easy for Americans to forget that the dedicated revolutionaries were actually a minority of the population. Roughly a third of the people were revolutionaries, a third were dedicated loyalists to the crown, and the other third were just keeping their heads down and trying to get through the whole affair in one piece. After the war, many loyalists fled to what is now Canada, others got on ships and sailed back to England, and the rest made their peace with events and became Americans.
In many ways, the Revolutionary War was a civil war.
Although I am no expert regarding the Revolutionary War, I wonder if defeated, would the Americans so inclined regroup, reassemble, and continue attacking the British investments in the Thirteen Colonies?
Indeed, how would history differ if the English lost the wars with France?
The influx of Loyalists into Canada caused Nova Scotia to be split into New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, and Quebec to be split into Upper and Lower Canada.
It really is fascinating to ponder, and it makes you realize that history could have taken many different turns. There is nothing inevitable about the way events actually played out.
Since they revolutionaries in France took a lot of inspiration from the American Revolution and the Declaration of Independence, I wonder how French history would’ve been affected if the 13 colonies had remained British possessions.
The small print at the bottom of the British Empires “Uncle Sambos Needs You” is remarkable
Anywho, as a libertarian, I am old enough to remember that crazy lawsuit, as I emphasize small “L”, for I have love, appreciation and at the same time very deep hatred, for billboards…and how the cause and salvation of freedom and liberty have ended up littering the landscape of the Deep South America…One wonders where property rights begin..and should end, in the land of the free milk and honey (peachy cobbler at the local chain gone wild Cracker Barrel is da best)…Who’s masses bought the advert “Make America Great Again” wholesale, by crook, line and sinker. That is all. Gotta run on. Thanks for Jaywalking, I mean writing Onward and Upward. Peace through superior mental firepower
One more for your reading list: "Kings Mountain" by Sharyn McCrumb. Her tale around the Revolutionary War battle in the SC Upstate, like any good novel, draws in the reader. No one is better at writing about the Appalachian "folk."
The people fighting the British in the American Revolution were Americans, Mr. Nordlinger. What else would they be? The Battle of Cowpens took place in 1781, and the United States declared itself a country in 1776.
Mr. Nordlinger: Regarding your reader, I fail to see how NATO "encroached on Russia." Russia has now demanded that Finland withdraw from NATO. It is clear Russia fears a NATO Article 5 response to their desired attack on Finland. Putin is obviously desperate not to accidentally fall out a window in the Kremlin.
“P.S. I would have said ‘A million.’ The billboard reads, ‘Over 950,000 South Carolinians …’ I would have said, ‘A million …’ Close enough.”
I’d go with “almost a million.” Can’t be too careful.
“You have overly subjective leanings toward Israel.” Of course. Everyone who disagrees with you is doing so for “subjective,” irrational reasons.
Jay raised an interesting point about using “American” to describe every man in the Continental Army who fought the British in the Battle of Cowpens on January17, 1781. Per Google AI, that Continental Army division, led by Brigadier General Daniel Morgan, included about 450 to 500 Continental regulars (from Maryland and Delaware) and roughly 800 to 1,000 state militiamen from North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, and Virginia.
I asked Google AI this question: “Europeans referred to colonists in North America as Americans but did the colonists? Didn't they identify as Virginians, Pennsylvanians, Marylanders, etc.?”
This was Google AI’s answer:
Yes, North American colonists primarily identified with their specific colony—such as Virginians, Pennsylvanians, or Marylanders—and as British subjects, rather than as "Americans" in a national sense.
• PRIMARY LOCAL AND IMPERIAL LOYALTIES: For most of the colonial era, a person's foundational identity was tied to their local province, town, or colony, as well as their status as a subject of the British Crown. Inter-colonial rivalries and vast geographic distances meant a resident of Massachusetts rarely felt a shared national kinship with a resident of South Carolina.
• GEOGRAPHIC VS. NATIONAL LABEL: While Europeans and British authorities used "American" as early as the 1600s, it functioned strictly as a geographic descriptor—much like calling someone a "southerner" or "islander"—rather than a nationality.
• SHIFT DURING THE REVOLUTION: A broader sense of a shared "American" identity began to take root through collective resistance to British taxation and policies in the 1760s and 1770s, accelerated by the Second Continental Congress officially adopting the name United States of America in 1776. However, strong state-level identities remained dominant for decades afterward.
Here are two of the links Google AI provided to information sources:
Colonial Identity: English or American?
https://billofrightsinstitute.org/activities/colonial-identity-english-or-american/
The word American didn’t begin as a bold national claim—it started as a simple way to describe people living across the Atlantic.
https://www.facebook.com/scienceexplorist/posts/the-word-american-didnt-begin-as-a-bold-national-claim-it-started-as-a-simple-wa/951301187454909/
Golly, the giant peach! My “Yankee” friends driving down from CT NY or NJ to start the new semester at Tulane ALL had to drive past that!!
Jay: I agree with Professor Thornton that the "Collected Works of William Shakespeare" is one of the greatest books ever written, but you cannot overlook the "The Collected Works of Sherlock Holmes" by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle!! First read them in 7th grade and was hooked on mysteries ever since. I reread them every few years. And do not forget the DVD sets, starring Basil Rathbone, then Jeremy Brett, and the modern version with Benedict Cumberbatch. I guess you have to say this old geezer is a Sherlock Holmes fan. 🤔😊
Camp Meeting....great album from Bruce Hornsby accompanied by two of the greatest...Jack DeJohnette and Christian McBride.
On another note,SC has the home to the greatest number of Loyalist and if not for the hill people of Tennessee and North Carolina,it may be more Tea Time than Tee Time down that way !
And Jay !!! Augusta G A ...home to the Godfather of Soul,Mr.Please,Please,Please himself ...the Hardest Working Man in Show Business:
JAMES BROWN !!!
That's a big miss pal !!
Give me their names-and-numbers. I’ll run debate interference.
Regarding the woman who will not subscribe due to your leanings towards Israel. Seems a bit short sighted to me. How does one learn to curate an opinion if they don't at least listen to opposing viewpoints? I don't agree with everything I read,but I read both sides. Same argument to folks that don't consider history worth studying. How do you know where you're going,if you don't know where you've been?
I apologize to any readers who are not comfortable with my take.
Between 1780 and 1820 or so, the largest cohort of immigrants to “Canada” were United Empire Loyalists who fled the Colonies or were driven out of your young Country.
So, even though these folks were technically Americans, they decided to leave. Canada, of course, was not yet a Dominion, but this is considered part of Canadian history. Those Loyalists are considered early Canadians.
I would describe the Revolutionary warriors as Americans, and the new, fledgling Country as America.
Even if the American side lost, and the British retained some standing, there would still remain that remnant of folks who believed in the bigger American ideal, and ethos.
I hope that makes sense, and I hope it sheds a different perspective on the discussion.
It isn’t Sunday morning with Super Jay.
Yes, it is easy to forget that the American Revolution did not just create the United States, it also created Canada. It did so by producing a division where no division had existed before. Prior to that revolution the eastern seaboard of North America (apart from what is now Florida) was made up entirely of British colonies, all equally subject to the Crown.
It’s an interesting thought experiment to wonder how things would have subsequently developed if the American Revolution had never happened, or if the revolutionaries had lost the war.
Edited to add: it’s also easy for Americans to forget that the dedicated revolutionaries were actually a minority of the population. Roughly a third of the people were revolutionaries, a third were dedicated loyalists to the crown, and the other third were just keeping their heads down and trying to get through the whole affair in one piece. After the war, many loyalists fled to what is now Canada, others got on ships and sailed back to England, and the rest made their peace with events and became Americans.
In many ways, the Revolutionary War was a civil war.
Great post, friend.
I think of that often.
Although I am no expert regarding the Revolutionary War, I wonder if defeated, would the Americans so inclined regroup, reassemble, and continue attacking the British investments in the Thirteen Colonies?
Indeed, how would history differ if the English lost the wars with France?
The influx of Loyalists into Canada caused Nova Scotia to be split into New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, and Quebec to be split into Upper and Lower Canada.
Fascinating to ponder.
It really is fascinating to ponder, and it makes you realize that history could have taken many different turns. There is nothing inevitable about the way events actually played out.
Since they revolutionaries in France took a lot of inspiration from the American Revolution and the Declaration of Independence, I wonder how French history would’ve been affected if the 13 colonies had remained British possessions.
The small print at the bottom of the British Empires “Uncle Sambos Needs You” is remarkable
Anywho, as a libertarian, I am old enough to remember that crazy lawsuit, as I emphasize small “L”, for I have love, appreciation and at the same time very deep hatred, for billboards…and how the cause and salvation of freedom and liberty have ended up littering the landscape of the Deep South America…One wonders where property rights begin..and should end, in the land of the free milk and honey (peachy cobbler at the local chain gone wild Cracker Barrel is da best)…Who’s masses bought the advert “Make America Great Again” wholesale, by crook, line and sinker. That is all. Gotta run on. Thanks for Jaywalking, I mean writing Onward and Upward. Peace through superior mental firepower
One more for your reading list: "Kings Mountain" by Sharyn McCrumb. Her tale around the Revolutionary War battle in the SC Upstate, like any good novel, draws in the reader. No one is better at writing about the Appalachian "folk."
Perhaps use "fledgling" as an adjective?
(I’m not quite sure how to write that.)
The people fighting the British in the American Revolution were Americans, Mr. Nordlinger. What else would they be? The Battle of Cowpens took place in 1781, and the United States declared itself a country in 1776.