10 Comments
User's avatar
Patrick Brennan's avatar

China should take a clue from Mr Trump, and deport people like Chow Hang-Tung and Joshua Wong. We need that kind of class and courage right here. As a matter of fact, I expect there are many such folk among the pictured UT grads. They are going to be disappointed.

The sad truth is that when Mr Trump launched his campaign in 2015, he took a position firmly based on racial discrimination. Colour of skin and accent of voice were (are still!) the bases for judgement. It says something about my fellow Americans that they nominated him to stand for the nation's highest executive office three times in succession. Even after Mr. Trump demonstrated his corruption, incompetence and treachery, they elected him anyway. That is why some candidates for state-wide office "play the race card," and why so many others do whatever it takes to avoid his disapproval. Courage and class may not put you in jail here, but it isn't likely to get you nominated for anything, either.

David K Taggart's avatar

1. Can't quite figure how federalism fits into an Israeli political party.

2. My go-to when I can't figure out an accent is, "Say, just what part of Texas are you from?"

Crawfurdmuir's avatar

Jay, it's strange to read the proposed platform of a putatively conservative party that does not include the institution of private property. Perhaps this is why it also says nothing about anti-communism.

The absence of such points raises a red flag (perhaps literally) because it brings to mind Conquest's second law - "Any organization not explicitly and constitutionally right-wing will sooner or later become left-wing." So will any party that does not dedicate itself to private property. Absent it, what constitutes "a free economy" or "individual rights"?

"Equality of opportunity" - well, there's room for a lot of mischief in that phrase. If we look at the people around us, the genuinely self-evident truth is that all men are NOT created equal - not physically, not intellectually, not even morally. Given the freedom to do so, any group of persons will soon manifest social and economic inequalities, based on their natural differences. Any effort to suppress this is bound to result in the loss of freedoms.

Those who advocate "equality of opportunity" are asserting that everyone must start from the same point - taking no cognizance that there are individual differences in the runners' abilities and drive even before the start of the footrace. Advocates of leveling will argue that the only way the race can start with equal opportunity for all is to require them first to be made equal in condition. Thus we are returned to the original dilemma of egalitarianism. Equality is not the compatriot of liberty, but rather its enemy.

Robert Kunold's avatar

Jay, sign me up to your party. One addition, to make sure the context of the other categories is fully understood: “limited government”

Benjy Compson's avatar

Chow Hang-tung. One woman with courage…If only the British Royal Navy had surrounded Hong Kong in June of 1997 had declared the treaty of a bygone era bye gone…oh, and declared China get a two party state because Western Civilisation does not negotiate with terrorists..and in defending the liberty of Hong Kongers, we are defending our own…what could have been, what should of been

Now, to Ho Bo French, who I should like to say this to his pure white trash face: When a stranger sojourns amongst you, you shall NOT vex him. For you shall treat the stranger as one BORN IN THE U.S.A. (like those proud to be Texans celebrating), I mean born amongst you. For you shall love your neighbor as yourself Bo…because we are ALL Heritage Americans created with unalienable rights to life, liberty amd the pursuit of happiness…All humans have a right to live in a free country, not just white trash like you Bo, who, Bo, all that agree with you i should, like, forgive me Jesus, not just get out of the country, but please get the F off my planet.

Jay, I love you, but we are way passed playing nice with human garbagemen like Bo French, J.D. Vance and tolerating TRUMPISM POISONS EVERYTHING…The rich pure white trash POSPOTUS “My friend Xi” needs to be declared an enemy of the people and an existential threat to Western Civilisation…I do not say that in jest, I say it because it is the truth…We have seen this bad movie before, where the alien and citizen are branded “unworthy of life” in The Fatherland…and my old man damn near ended up in Robert E. Lee’s backyard (one of the greatest f u war spoils of all time) in…1945. FOR GODS SAKE THIS WISE GUY CANNOT REMAIN IN WHITE POWER…We do not need a new party, we need one man with courage to speak to the Orangeman’s pure white trash ugly face in such a manner that he finds a soul and turns death white….Our Civilisation is hanging by the skin of our teeth. We the Living in Kakistocracy and there is an axis of evil Putin, Xi, Un…Trumpism needs to be eliminated, like the Nazism, from the face of the Earth, like so yesterday….so Chow Hang-tung can live free and die a happy death. Gotta run on. Thanks for taking my rant Onward and Upward. Please GOD HELP U.S. and deliver U.S. from Evil. Take The Don…I mean Calgon take me away. Peace through superior mental firepower

Wolfy Jack's avatar

I read Nick's piece in The Dispatch. Was it a bit of "nut picking" .

I am all for the meritocracy, but in my own field, medicine, I do perhaps have some nativist sentiment, in that I feel a country as wealthy as the US should be able to educate enough doctors not to have to steal them from places that need them more, or have Americans have to go to the Caribbean by virtue of only having a 3.4 instead of a 3.5.

That we benefit from smart foreign born people coming here is good and Trump is trying to destroy that as the world's smartest college entrants have been turning away from the US and choosing UK and Canada, resulting in our losing our lead in research to China which now garners the most in new patents.

On the other hand I think we could do a better job of training our own physicians, techies, and nurses rather than importing them. If anything I favor tilting the immigrant pool to the " tired, your poor, huddled masses yearning to breathe free" like my grandparents who were denied education abroad but worked in the sweatshops so their children and grandchildren prospered. Most of the elite specialists coming from abroad come from wealthy families, not the huddled masses. And why are they huddling.

Crawfurdmuir's avatar

One of the reasons why "Most of the elite specialists coming from abroad come from wealthy families, not the huddled masses" is that their wealthy families abroad can support them through residencies in their native countries. Having completed them, they then move here, pass their boards, and are admitted to practice.

By contrast, the number of specialty residencies available in the United States is strictly limited. This has served to restrict supply of specialists and to increase their earning potential significantly just as one might expect an oligopoly to do.

I am a recipient of the services of such specialists - my ophthalmologist is Chinese, my gastroenterologist is Indian, and my internist is Vietnamese. I have no complaint about them either professionally or personally. Still, it would be well for our medical-educational establishment to consider reforms of the system that brought the present situation about.

Wolfy Jack's avatar

You need to complete a US residency to practice, and the foreign doctors might have done med school abroad but residency in the US.

The number of specialty residencies is limited but there are more residency spots in the primary care residencies than medical school graduates which is how most of the foreign trained doctors come in. And primary spots include Internal Medicine from which you could then go on to do a specialty like Rheumatology or Cardiology (some specialties you go directly to the specialty like Orthopedics).

So, I think the main need is for more medical school positions. Currently we only graduate enough MDs to fill 57% of our residency positions, then we pick up 18.5% from osteopathic school (DOs, at one time Osteopathy was similar to Chiropractic but it is now totally mainstream medicine and basically an end run for people who didn't get into medical school and graduates go to regular US residencies). The remaining 24% are foreign medical school graduates.

It is not that I dont like foreign doctors but it seems odd that American students have to go to the Caribbean to train.

Dra Wiersema's avatar

That single dialogue between Chow Hang-tung and the judge is enough to mark one's entire life as a success.

Here is a smile creating thought ... for those old enough to remember her ... Just imagine what Florence King would have written about Trump. (former NR columnist)

Donald Ashman's avatar

Jay, I have to tell you I am a full on sucker for your brand of breezy, yet straight to the heart and head, brand of journalism.

I have mentioned this before, but no other journalist of whom I can recall does as fine a job as you with respect to political prisoners of conscience. The only one that compares is Canadian journalist Terry Glavin, in my opinion.

I was appalled and astonished at the tweet from Mr. French.

One of “Donald Ashman’s Ten Tenets of Principled Conservatism is the notion of “support for a mutually advantageous system of immigration that benefits both the immigrant, and the host Country.”

These kookaroos aren’t conservatives; heck, they are nothing but civil, and social, and international disruptors.

Your bit about Heritage Americans made me smile. It reminds me of an exchange about which I have read, between Margaret Thatcher and the press. Margaret Thatcher was talking about British heritage, values, civility and the social customs that unite the Brits. She was asked “what are those values?”

She replied, “Exactly those values the IRA are trying to bomb out of existence.”

Great piece, Jay; a certified pleasure to read.